Page images
PDF
EPUB

H. Bryer, Priuter, Bridge-street, Blackfriars, London.

[merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors]

546

393

481

274
127
537

Beaufort's Karamania

Bervard's, Mad. Jeunes Vendéens

Bigland's Letters on French History

Blunt's Siraroger's Guide to the City of New York
Boyue's D scourse on the Mil'ennium
Bullar's Memoirs of the late Rev. W. Kngsbury
Carey's Translat on of Dante's Vis on, or HH1, Purgatory, and Paradise
Clarke's, Dr. Travels through various countries of Eurupe, Asia, and Africa

Part Ill. Scandinavia

Coalition and France

Colquhoun's Treatise on the Covenant of Grace

Consutation of Calvinin
Carwen's State of Ireland

556

509

177

483

56
43

Fearon's Sketches of America

153

Flinders's Voyage to Tina Australis

359

Freeston's Advice to a Young Minister of the Gospel

88

Golownin's Recollections of Japan

244

Gurney's Notes on a Visit to some Prisons in Scotland, and the North of

England

235

Hewlett's Commen'aries an I donotations in the Holy Scriptures

345
Horne's Introduction to the Critical Kowled;e of the Holy Scriptures 21, 182
Inquiry concerning the $ te of ancient Palibothra

423
King's, Dr. Political and Literary Anecdotes of bis own Times

89
Lacey's Familiar Review of the Lie of David, King of Israel

484
Law's, Dr. Scriptural Doctrine of Mau's Salvation

36
Letters on the Constraiord Celibyscy of the Cleryy of the Church of Rome 265
Letters on the Importance', Duty, and Arivadesets of Ear y Rising

356
Letters to the Righi Hur. Rusere Peel, E:q. M. P. on the pernic ous Efects of
a Variable Standard of Value

405

List of Works recently published

103. 199. 299 401. 506.610

Merlet's Traducteur

572

Milford's Observations, Moral, Politial and Antiquarian, made in a Tour

through the South of France

378

Moeus's Choix de Lecture pour les jeunes Gens

393

Moniagu's liquiries.respecting the Punishment of Death for Crimes without

Violence

1

64

1

PAGE

Narrative of the Mission to Otaheite, and other Islands in the South Seas 169

Nautical Essays

482

Paddock's Narrative of the Shipwreck of the Oswego

64

Park's Nugæ Modernæ

84

Pegge's Curialia Miscellanea, or, Anecdotes of Old Tines

275

Peter Bell; a Lyrical Ballad

473

Picturesque Tour through France, Switzerland, &c.

378

Punishment of Death in the case of Forgery; its Injustice maintained
Raffles's Letters during a Tour through France, &c.

171
Reformation of the Catholic Church in Germany, and the Downfall of Papal
Authority

462
Reply to the Author of a Letter to the Right Hon. Robert Peel, Esq. M. P.

405
Rhodes's Peak Scenery

530
Riley's Lois of the American Brig Commerce

Roberts's Manual of Prophery

384

Roby's Lectures on the Principal Evidences of Revealed Religion

Rogers's Human Life, a Poem

218
Select Literary Information

100, 196, 296, 399, 504, 609
Sermons by the late Rev. Charles Wesley

150
Small's Sermons to Young People

259
Speech of the Marquis of Lansdowne, June 3, i818
Spence's Letters from the North Highlands

479
Staël's, Mad. la Baronne de, Considerations sur les Principaux Evénemens
de la Revolution Françoise

201, 316, 488
Tarver's Dictionnaire des Verbes François

579
Taylor's Annals of Health and long Life

87
Mrs. and Miss, Correspondence between a Mother and her Daughter

at School

394

Mrs. Reciprocal Duties of Parents and Children

394

Thomson's Discourses on the Young warned against the Enticements of
Sinners

259

Thornton's Sermons on the most important Doctrines of the Gospel

376

Thurtle's History of France

481

Transactions of the Literary Society of Bombay

423

Two Papers; a Theatrical Critique, and an Essay on Sonnet Writing, &c. 473

Warner's, Rebecca, Epistolary Curiosities

572

Original Letters from Richard Baxter Prior

ib.

Wilson's, Daniel, Sermons

226

Wix's Reflections on the Expediency of a Counsel of the Church of Enge

land and the Church of Rome being bolden, to accommodate religious

differences

301, 440, 581

Wright's Philosophy of Elocution

389

Yeates's Indian Church History

250

THE

ECLECTIC REVIEW,

FOR JANUARY, 1819.

Art. I. 1. Speech of the Marquis of Lansdowne in the House of Lords,

June 3, 1818, on moving for certain Information relative to the State of the Prisons in the United Kingdom. Published by the Society for the Improvement of Prison Discipline, and for the

Reformation of Juvenile Offenders. 8vo. pp. 16. price 6d. 1818. 2. Some Inquiries respecting the Punishment of Death for Crimes

without Violence. By Basil Montagu, Esq. 8vo. pp. 120. London,

1818. 3. The Punishment of Death in the Case of Forgery ; its Injustice and

Impolicy maintained. 8vo. pp. 32. price 1s. 1818. IF F there be any truth in the omen which Lord Bacon deemed

the only infallible source of political prophecy, the predominent opinions of men in general between twenty and thirty, no event may with more confidence be predicted, than some speedy legislative reformation of our penal code. Such a measure has long appeared highly desirable, not simply on the ground of humanity, but because the multiplicity of capital punishments bas of itself necessitated a partial repeal of the sanctions of our criminal law, introducing by this means an uncertainty into the administration of justice, which defeats the very intention of the legislature. The alarming increase of offences has tended to strengthen this opinion, and to awaken at the same time a suspicion as to the efficacy of penal severities in deterring from the commission of crime. Imperfect,' remarked Dr. Colquhoun, in a work published nearly twenty years ago, 'must be either 'the plan, or the execution, or both, of our criminal code, if ' crimes are found to increase.' Crimes have increased, and those crimes especially have increased, upon which the laws denounce the punishnient of death. At the same time, it has been found impracticable to push further the system of severity. The relaxation of the laws bas accordingly almost kept pace with the multiplication of offences. Punishment has become VOL. XI. N. S.

B

[ocr errors]
[ocr errors]

more uncertain, in proportion as the laws have grown more severe, or as the field for the application of their severity has extended. The example made of the sufferer is, under these circumstances, deprived of its beneficial influence, inasmuch as the crime wbich is the ground of his sentence, is not the real cause of his suffering that sentence. Those selected for execution, at the discretion of the judge, endure the penalty, not because they are condemned to die, but because they are excluded from the general respite. The magistracy has, in fact, been the great innovator: in this extensive exercise of its discretional powers, it has anticipated those changes to which it has now become the business of the legislature to give permanence. It is the judges of our criminal courts wbo are chargeable with beginning the desired reform; they have made the rule the exception, and the exception has become the rule.* Nor does there exist any disapprobation of this systematic lenity. Among all the expedients devised for checking the progress of delinquency, no individual has been found hardy enough to propose the remedying of the discrepancy between the law and the practice, by making the punishment of death even generally consequent upon the sentence. But still, this discrepancy is felt to be an evil; and if the practice cannot be brought nearer to the standard of the law, it is natural to inquire whether the law might not without danger be reconciled with the practice. A very high judicial authority (Sir W. Grant) has argued, that . as they cannot both be right, the question is,

which is wrong, and where the remedy is to be applied.' "Now I think,' added that learned and highly respected individual, on the occasion alluded to, “the pructice is right.' The public at large seem now prepared very generally to second this decision. The conduct of a recent Loudon Jury, though attributable, in great measure, to dissatisfaction with the nature of the evidence before them, has spoken pretty loudly the prevailing reluctance to place the life of an offender at the discretion of a judge. In fact, the question is now before the country, and it becomes the indispensable duty of the great

Sir Samuel Romilly stated before the House of Commons, that out of 1872 committed to Newgate within the seven years preceding 1810, charged with the capital offence of stealing in dwelling houses and shop-lifting, only one was executed. Again : it was stated on the 25th March, 1818, that during the preceding twelve years, 655 persons had been indicted for privately stealing, of which number 113 had been capitally convicted, and of these 113 not one had been executed ; 365 of the 655 had been found guilty of simple larceny only; that is to say, 365 persons had either been improperly charged with a capital offence, or were acquitted of the capital part of the charge, by the juries, in violation of their oaths.

« PreviousContinue »